There comes a point in almost every growing business where you realise you can't keep doing it all yourself.
What started as just you has gradually become something much bigger. More enquiries. More clients. More opportunities. More moving parts. More decisions.
At first, it's exciting.
Growth is what you've been working towards.
Then, almost without noticing, the excitement starts to come with a little bit of overwhelm.
The inbox is fuller than it used to be.
The to-do list never quite gets finished.
The workdays become longer.
The evenings become shorter.
And eventually, one thought starts creeping into your mind.
"I think it's time to hire someone."
Whether you're recruiting your very first employee or contractor, or you're adding your fifth, tenth or twentieth team member, recruitment can feel overwhelming.
Not because hiring people is impossible.
Because there are so many different ways to approach it.
Should you recruit yourself?
Should you ask your VA or OBM to coordinate the process?
Should you engage a recruitment agency?
Should you work with a recruitment partner like Emerald HQ?
How do you know which option is right?
The truth is, there isn't one right answer.
Every business is different.
Every role is different.
Every business owner has different strengths, different budgets and different levels of confidence when it comes to recruitment.
As businesses continue to grow, many eventually reach the point where they employ an internal HR Coordinator, People & Culture Manager or even an internal recruiter. At that stage, recruitment becomes part of somebody's role because it's happening frequently enough to justify having that expertise in-house.
Most small businesses aren't there yet.
Recruitment is important.
It just isn't happening often enough to justify employing someone whose sole responsibility is finding great people.
Instead, they look externally for support when the need arises.
The challenge is that "recruitment support" can mean very different things depending on who you're talking to.
Some people simply need help coordinating the administration.
Others want somebody to manage the entire recruitment process.
Some businesses need access to specialist candidate networks.
Others simply want somebody to help them make better hiring decisions.
None of those approaches are wrong.
They're simply different.
At Emerald HQ, one of our core values is education and empowerment. We don't believe in convincing people to choose our way simply because it's our service. We'd much rather help business owners understand all of their options so they can make the decision that's right for their business.
Because ultimately, our goal isn't to convince you to work with Emerald HQ.
Our goal is to help you build a great team.
Sometimes that will be with us.
Sometimes it won't.
And that's okay.
So, let's look at some of the most common ways businesses recruit, where each approach works well, and the trade-offs worth considering before deciding what's right for you.
Option One - DIY Recruitment
For many business owners, DIY recruitment is the natural starting point.
After all, nobody knows your business better than you do.
You understand your clients.
You understand your team.
You understand your culture.
You understand what success looks like.
So when it's time to recruit, it makes sense to think, "I'll just do it myself."
For some businesses, that's exactly the right decision.
Particularly if recruitment is something you genuinely enjoy, you have the time available to invest in it, or you've recruited successfully before. DIY recruitment gives you complete control over every stage of the process. You decide how the role is positioned, where it's advertised, who progresses through the recruitment
process and ultimately who joins your team.
For many business owners, that's exactly how they want it.
There's absolutely nothing wrong with that.
The challenge is that good recruitment involves far more than simply posting an advertisement and interviewing candidates.
One of the biggest misconceptions we see is that writing a job advertisement is simply describing the role.
It isn't.
It's marketing.
You're competing against every other business advertising for similar talent. Candidates aren't just comparing salaries. They're comparing businesses, cultures, flexibility, opportunities and whether they can picture themselves working with you. The way you position your business and communicate the opportunity has a huge influence over who chooses to apply.
A great role described poorly won't attract great candidates.
Just as importantly, recruitment comes with legal responsibilities that many business owners aren't aware of until they're already in the middle of the process.
Knowing what you can and can't ask during interviews.
Understanding the wording that should be avoided in advertisements.
Ensuring your recruitment process is fair, consistent and compliant.
Managing candidate communication professionally.
These aren't things most business owners are taught.
Nor should they need to be.
Then there's the time involved.
Reviewing resumes.
Communicating with applicants.
Scheduling interviews.
Conducting interviews.
Reference checking.
Negotiating offers.
Managing unsuccessful candidates.
It all adds up, particularly if you're trying to fit recruitment around running the rest of your business.
DIY recruitment can absolutely be the right solution.
It simply requires you to wear another hat within your business, and to be confident that you're making informed recruitment decisions along the way.
DIY recruitment may be right for you if:
✔️ You have the time to dedicate to recruitment.
✔️ You enjoy interviewing and assessing candidates.
✔️ You recruit regularly enough to build your own experience.
✔️ You want complete ownership of every decision.
Things to consider:
✖️ Recruitment is far more time consuming than most people expect.
✖️ Writing a job advertisement that attracts the right candidates is a marketing skill, not an administrative task.
✖️ Understanding recruitment legislation and best practice requires ongoing learning.
✖️ It's easy to recruit based on instinct rather than evidence.
✖️ Managing large volumes of applications can quickly become overwhelming.
The biggest advantage of DIY recruitment is control.
The biggest responsibility is that every decision sits with you.
Option Two - VA, OBM or Administrative Support
For many business owners, the next logical step isn't outsourcing recruitment.
It's asking someone already supporting the business to help.
Perhaps that's your Virtual Assistant.
Your OBM.
Your Executive Assistant.
Or another member of your administration team.
This can be a fantastic option, particularly if you already have somebody who knows your business well.
They understand how you work.
They know your clients.
They're familiar with your systems, your communication style and the day-to-day running of the business.
That existing knowledge can make the recruitment process feel much more manageable because you're not starting from scratch with somebody new.
In many cases, they can take a significant amount of work off your plate.
Posting advertisements.
Communicating with candidates.
Scheduling interviews.
Managing calendars.
Following up references.
Keeping everything organised behind the scenes.
If the biggest challenge you're facing is simply finding the time to manage the recruitment process, having somebody coordinate those moving parts can make a huge difference.
Where business owners sometimes become caught out, though, is assuming that coordinating recruitment and leading recruitment are the same thing.
They're not.
A great VA or administrator is incredibly skilled at creating efficient processes.
They'll keep candidates informed.
They'll make sure interviews are booked.
They'll follow up outstanding information.
They'll keep everything moving.
Those are all incredibly valuable skills.
But recruitment is about much more than moving candidates from one stage to the next
.
Behind every stage of the recruitment process sits a strategy.
Why are we asking this interview question?
What behaviour are we trying to uncover?
What concerns should this answer raise?
Why are we completing reference checks this way instead of another way?
What risks are we trying to identify before someone joins the business?
Those aren't administrative decisions.
They're recruitment decisions.
The same applies before the recruitment process even begins.
How should the role be positioned?
Should this be an employee or contractor?
Are we attracting the right audience?
Is the salary aligned with the market?
What behaviours should we be assessing?
How do we compare two candidates who both look great on paper but bring completely different strengths?
Those decisions are built on recruitment knowledge and experience.
Without that background, it's very easy for recruitment to become a well-managed process that isn't necessarily a well-managed recruitment strategy.
That doesn't mean using your VA or OBM is the wrong decision.
Far from it.
For many businesses, it's exactly the right solution.
Particularly if you're confident leading the recruitment process yourself and simply need somebody to help manage the administration that comes with it.
VA, OBM or administration support may be right for you if:
✔️ You're confident making recruitment decisions yourself.
✔️ You already know what the role looks like.
✔️ You simply need help coordinating the recruitment process.
✔️ You already have someone who understands your business and systems.
Things to consider:
✖️ Most VAs, OBMs and administrators aren't recruitment specialists.
✖️ They'll usually coordinate the recruitment process rather than lead the recruitment strategy.
✖️ You'll still be responsible for defining the role, assessing candidates and making hiring decisions.
✖️ Without recruitment experience, they may not recognise behavioural indicators, hiring risks or opportunities that an experienced recruiter would identify.
The biggest advantage of this approach is efficiency.
The biggest consideration is that you're still relying on your own recruitment knowledge to make the important hiring decisions.
Option Three - Recruitment Agency
For many businesses, engaging a recruitment agency is exactly the right decision.
Agency recruiters play an incredibly important role in the recruitment industry, particularly when businesses need specialist expertise, confidential recruitment or access to candidates they simply wouldn't reach on their own.
Like every recruitment option, though, understanding where agencies provide the greatest value helps you decide whether they're the right fit for your business.
One of the biggest advantages of working with a specialist recruitment agency is their network.
The best industry recruiters don't just know the market.
They know the people within it.
They've spent years building relationships with candidates, understanding industry movements and maintaining databases of people who may not even be actively looking for a new role but would consider the right opportunity.
That's incredibly valuable when you're recruiting for niche or highly specialised positions.
If you're looking for an experienced mining engineer, a specialist healthcare professional or a senior executive, an industry recruiter may already know exactly who they're going to call before the advertisement is even written.
That's where agencies can provide enormous value.
They're not simply advertising your role.
They're opening doors that many businesses couldn't access on their own.
If, however, an agency still needs to advertise publicly to find candidates, it's worth understanding what additional value they're'll be providing throughout the process. That doesn't automatically make them the wrong choice, but it does change the conversation about why you're engaging them in the first place and what expertise you're investing in.
Like any profession, agencies also vary significantly in their approach.
Some take the time to genuinely understand your business, your culture and the type of person who'll thrive within your team.
Others operate at a much higher volume, where speed becomes a bigger focus.
That's why choosing the right agency is just as important as deciding to use one.
One perception that occasionally exists within the market is that agencies are primarily focused on filling the vacancy as quickly as possible, particularly where guarantee periods apply. Whether that's true depends entirely on the agency and consultant you're working with, but it's a worthwhile conversation to have before engaging any recruitment provider.
Ask questions.
Understand their process.
Find out how they assess candidates.
Ask how they get to know your business.
The more aligned their approach is with your expectations, the better your experience is likely to be.
A recruitment agency may be right for you if:
✔️ You're recruiting for a specialist or niche industry role.
✔️ You want access to an established candidate network.
✔️ You'd like to outsource most or all of the recruitment process.
✔️ You need a confidential recruitment process.
Things to consider:
✖️ Agency recruitment is generally a higher financial investment than other recruitment options.
✖️ The quality and approach varies significantly between agencies and individual consultants.
✖️ It's important to understand how they'll represent your business, assess candidates and measure recruitment success.
The biggest advantage of a recruitment agency is access to recruitment expertise and established candidate networks.
The biggest consideration is finding an agency whose approach aligns with the way you want to grow your team.
Option Four - A Recruitment Partner Like Emerald HQ
If you've read our previous blogs in this series, you'll probably notice that our approach looks a little different to the options we've already discussed.
That's because we don't see recruitment as something that starts when you decide to advertise a role.
We see it as something that starts much earlier.
Long before the job advertisement is written.
Long before candidates apply.
Long before interviews are booked.
For us, recruitment is really about helping businesses make good hiring decisions.
Sometimes that results in recruitment.
Sometimes it results in a completely different conversation.
We've had business owners come to us convinced they needed another employee, only to realise that what they actually needed was clearer delegation, better systems or a redesign of the roles that already existed within the business.
We've also had businesses come to us knowing they needed to recruit, but having no idea where to start. They knew they were busy. They knew they needed help. They just weren't sure what that help actually looked like.
Both businesses needed support.
But they didn't need the same support.
That's why we don't have a single recruitment process that every client moves through.
Instead, we step into the process wherever we're needed.
Sometimes that's right at the beginning, helping define the role, clarify responsibilities and work out what success should actually look like.
Sometimes it's supporting with advertising, screening candidates and coordinating interviews.
Sometimes it's conducting interviews, completing reference checks and helping clients compare candidates objectively.
And sometimes we're simply there as a sounding board, helping a business owner work through one of the biggest decisions they'll make for their team.
Every business is different.
Every role is different.
So the support should be different too.
One of the things we hear most often from clients is that it never felt like they were working with an external recruiter.
It felt like we were part of their team.
We think that's exactly how it should feel.
Because we're not trying to learn enough about your business to fill a vacancy.
We're trying to understand your business well enough to represent it properly.
That means understanding your culture.
Your values.
The way your team communicates.
The type of person who thrives in your environment.
Where your business is heading over the next few years.
And how this particular role contributes to that journey.
Without that understanding, it's incredibly difficult to confidently say whether somebody is the right fit.
A great candidate for one business can be completely the wrong fit for another.
Not because they're not capable.
Because every business is different.
That's why we spend so much time understanding the business before we start talking about candidates.
Emerald HQ may be right for you if:
✔️ You'd like support before, during or after recruitment, rather than simply advertising a role.
✔️ You'd like somebody to challenge your thinking and help define what your business actually needs.
✔️ You value finding the right long-term fit over simply filling a vacancy.
✔️ You'd like a recruitment partner who understands both recruitment and the realities of growing a small business.
Things to consider:
✖️ We aren't industry-specific recruiters, so for highly specialised or niche technical roles, an industry recruitment agency with an established candidate network may be the stronger option.
✖️ Our approach starts with strategy, role design and understanding your business, so it isn't designed for businesses looking for the fastest possible vacancy fill without taking the time to define the role properly.
✖️ We work alongside our clients rather than replacing them in the decision-making process. If you're looking for a completely hands-off recruitment experience, another recruitment model may be a better fit.
✖️ We'll ask a lot of questions before we start recruiting. Sometimes those conversations confirm it's time to hire. Other times, they uncover a different solution altogether.
The biggest advantage of working with Emerald HQ is that our support is designed around your business, not around a fixed recruitment process.
The biggest consideration is that our approach is intentionally collaborative. We believe the best hiring decisions happen when recruitment expertise and business knowledge come together, rather than one replacing the other.
So... Which Option Is Right?
After reading all of that, you might be hoping for a simple answer.
"Just tell me which one is best."
The truth is...
There isn't one.
Every one of these recruitment options has a place.
We've seen businesses recruit brilliantly themselves because they had the time, confidence and experience to do it well.
We've seen VAs and OBMs keep recruitment projects running seamlessly because the business owner already knew exactly what they were looking for.
We've seen specialist recruitment agencies find incredible candidates that businesses simply never would've reached on their own.
And we've had the privilege of partnering with businesses that wanted somebody to help them think strategically about the entire recruitment journey, from defining the role through to welcoming the right person into their team.
None of those approaches are wrong.
The best recruitment solution is the one that matches your business, your circumstances and the role you're trying to fill.
Before deciding which path to take, ask yourself:
❔ How much time do I realistically have to dedicate to recruitment?
❔ How confident am I making hiring decisions?
❔ Am I looking for administrative support, recruitment expertise or strategic guidance?
❔ Is this a general role or a highly specialised position?
❔ What level of involvement do I want throughout the recruitment process?
The answers to those questions will usually point you towards the approach that's the best fit for your business.
At Emerald HQ, we're passionate about helping businesses build great teams.
If that means working with us, we'd love to be part of the journey.
If it means pointing you towards a specialist recruiter or encouraging you to recruit yourself because you're well-equipped to do so, we're equally happy to have helped you make an informed decision.
Because at the end of the day, recruitment has never been about filling vacancies.
It's about helping businesses find the right people, in the right way, at the right time.
And that's something worth getting right.
Ash + Emerald HQ 💎
Comments